Saturday, March 22, 2014

Healer Gail Thackray on her first visit to John of God


"The Secret" - Is there anything Christian about it?--working4christ2 -- Considering leaving the faith and returning to the synagogues to wait for someone else

ok


Thread Tools

Search Thread

Display














#1
Old Yesterday, 4:31 pm


New Member

Join Date: February 20, 2014
Posts: 327
Religion: Catholic

Default Considering leaving the faith and
returning to the synagogues to wait for someone else


Many of you already know my story. For those of
you that do not, here it is:

I grew up in a protestant congregation, not
Catholic.

I have really wanted to get married from as early as I could
remember. Unfortunately, I grew up in a somewhat disfunctional household. Also,
I have Asperger's Syndrome and both of these factors have worked against me. As
a child, I turned to the people on staff at the protestant congregation where we
attended to get the help I needed that I wasn't getting at home or anywhere
else.

Instead of doing anything to actually help me with the things I
needed help with, I was continually told that Jesus wanted to keep me single my
whole life for his glory (and other stupid reasons. They did this because it was
easier and more convenient that actually spending time to help me. But as a
child, I didn't understand that). I spent entire years during my teens very
deeply and morbidly depressed from this and the fear of Hell was the only thing
that prevented me from committing suicide a great deal of the time.

In my
late teens and early twenties, I had come to the conclusion that Christianity
"wasn't working" and so started looking for a way out. Over the course of a
couple of years of studying different subjects, like science and philosophy, I
deconverted and became an atheist.

Some years later, I read a protestant
Bible for entirely nonreligious reasons. Along the way, I came to believe in the
God of the OT but rejected the God of the NT as the NT didn't match up with the
OT (I learned later about the deuterocanonical books and they DO make a
difference).

Considering my experiences, it made perfect sense to me
that the Jews had been right all along and so I went to a Rabbinical Jewish
Synagogue and began studying to convert.

Over the course of a few months
I came to believe in God very deeply. It wasn't the same as when I was a child.
When I was a child, I often felt like I was just faking it because the
'miracles' always happened to someone else and when I wasn't looking. None of my
prayers were ever answered and no one was ever concerned about my needs, only
that I parrotted back their dogma. I grew to hate God and Jesus. I also grew to
think of Christians as being deeply selfish and narcissistic and ultimately a
force for evil in the world. I was deeply relieved to "find out that God and
Jesus wasn't real" and spoke out against religion and Christianity for 10 years,
during my 20's and early 30's.

In the synagogue, I found the real God of
the universe. Nowhere along the way was I ever asked to set aside my reason but
instead was encouraged to use it. I learned that that real God, The God of
Israel, really did love me and had given the world the Jews and the Jewish
religion to prove it. Within the Torah and the Mitzvot, I found the answers to
all life's problems. For the first time in my life, I really felt like I had a
real personal relationship with God and I grew to deeply love that
God.

Also, for the first time in my life, I saw the promises of the Bible
actually coming to life. The biggest and best example was that they taught that
God wanted me to marry and every Jew in the synagogue wanted me to get married.
In fact, some of them would even stress to me at length how important it was
that I get married. They were all ready and willing to help me toward this.. I
only needed but to ask.

For the first time in my life, I didn't feel the
cross of singleness at all as I had complete reassurance that all my needs would
be met by the God of Israel through His Chosen people, the Jews. And so, for the
first time in my life, I was in no hurry to get married. Instead, I wanted to
focus on converting to Judaism and getting my life as a Jew in order.

One
of the guys in the synagogue didn't wait for me though. He kind of jumped the
gun and started trying to act as a matchmaker. He was no good at it. I think one
of the women he tried to hook me up with might have even been a lesbian (I don't
know for sure), but it's the effort that counted.

Attending the synagogue
was as joyful and happy as I've ever been in my life.

The problem I had
was that I could never keep my mouth shut. If I found a good thing, I wanted to
share it with EVERYONE. And so I wanted to become a Jewish missionary and spread
the message. I thought it was a crying shame that we got stuck with Christianity
when Judaism was the real thing. They were against this idea as they insisted
that Judaism was not a proselytizing religion. People came to Judaism on their
own, not through the work of missionaries. I got to looking online and other
places and I came to find their were no Jewish missionary organizations. This
greatly troubled me.

Another thing that greatly troubled me was that,
after about a year of attending synagogue, it really began to seek in more and
more that the "Christianity" that I grew up with could not have been the
religion that Jesus founded. The religion I grew up with was so completely
different that it didn't even remotely resemble the source religion.


Both of these factors combined sent me looking for the real historical
Christianity. Without going into a bunch of details, I did a ton of research and
come to discover it had really been the Catholic Church the entire
time.

Along the way, I became a believer in Jesus. I had come to believe
that Jesus was the messiah because the Catholic Christian religion religion
resembled Judaism so closely. I had come to believe that Jesus had taken the
Jewish religion and spread it all over the globe, through the Catholic
Church.

I made a decision to get confirmed as I expect to find in the
Church what I had found in Judaism.

That has not been the case.

Reply With Quote




#2
Old Yesterday, 4:31 pm


New Member

Join Date: February 20, 2014
Posts: 327
Religion: Catholic

Default Re: Considering leaving the faith and
returning to the synagogues to wait for someone else


(continued)

At first, I could hardly wait
until my two years were up so that I could go and become a missionary and spread
this all over the world. But the longer I have been a Catholic, the more I have
come to regret my decision.

Since I have gotten confirmed, two years ago
this Easter, no one has expressed any concern whatsoever over my status as a
single. Several people have suggested that I become a priest and others have
suggested that maybe God doesn't want me to marry.

I am once again, in
the name of Jesus, left carrying the heavy, cruel, hateful, abominable cross of
singleness.

To me, the God of the Jews, the God of the universe, the God
of Israel, is the God that wants me to get married and has provided his people
to give me all the help I need with that. To me, the Jews are the people that
want me to marry.

And the King of the Jews is the Jew that will introduce
me to my wife.

I have a lot of academic and intellectual knowledge of how
and why Jesus is the Messiah but in practice and experience, I have not seen him
or his church live up to the promise of the Messiah in my life.

The
cross of singleness is not just singleness but also the cross of the
selfishness, apathy and narcissism of Christians. It is easier to turn a blind
eye and say, "Well God just wants you to be single" then it is to actually do
anything to help me with what I need help with.

The devils in Hell can
leave me single and say the same things.

I want to believe in Jesus. I
really don't want to leave the Church because I want to be force for good in the
world and I want to spread the way, the light and the truth to every one
else.

I really do want Jesus and his Church to be that light, that way
and that truth. But I'm not seeing it. MY messiah doesn't turn a blind eye to
the suffering and misfortune of others and say, "for my glory" but instead puts
his own selfishness aside to help and relieve them.

If Jesus is going to
treat me this way, what's to say that he will not treat everyone else the same.
I want to offer people answers, not just more pain and suffering.

Reply With Quote




#3
Old Yesterday, 4:52 pm


New Member

Join Date: February 20, 2014
Posts: 327
Religion: Catholic

Default Re: Considering leaving the faith and
returning to the synagogues to wait for someone else


Another point was that in Judaism, I found people
ready and willing to be my mentors. Since becoming a Christian, I have been left
on my own. I am as alone now as I ever was as an atheist or as a child. I've
made acquaintances with the people that I attend church with but I'm reluctant
to call any of them friends.

No one calls when I miss church to check up
on me, no one is acting to be my spiritual adviser, counselor or leader, the
priest barely has any time for me.

I have been left to fly sola. When I
first converted, I would tell people that the difference between Catholicism and
protestantism was that Catholicism was about community and loving each other as
Christ loved us while protestantism, with all it's sola's, was ultimately sola
vita.

But I'm a Catholic and I live the Sola Vita now as much as I ever
did as a protestant. Why did I ever give up Judaism for this?

Reply With Quote




#4
Old Yesterday, 5:09 pm


Regular Member
Prayer Warrior

Join Date: April 9, 2005
Posts: 3,044
Religion: Catholic Convert 2008

Default Re: Considering leaving the faith and
returning to the synagogues to wait for someone else


I'm really not sure how to address this whole
issue. I find it overwhelming and wonder if you aren't co dependent on people in
general. All your actions have been reactions to what other people do "for you".


All I can do is pray for you. I don't see any of this as a religious
issue at all.

Reply With Quote




#5
Old Yesterday, 5:22 pm


Junior Member

Join Date: August 13, 2013
Posts: 137
Religion: Catholic

Default Re: Considering leaving the faith and
returning to the synagogues to wait for someone else


It sort of sounds like you give up on your beliefs
when they don't seem to work out for you especially.

What exactly should
Catholics be helping you with in regards to a wife?

__________________
everything's okay in the end
and if it's it not okay then
it's not the end

Abortion is murder. Abortion kills children.

Reply With Quote




#6
Old Yesterday, 5:30 pm


New Member

Join Date: November 28, 2012
Posts: 15
Religion: Roman Catholic

Default Re: Considering leaving the faith and
returning to the synagogues to wait for someone else


I'm very sorry to hear about your suffering. I'm
sure you've already heard this, but I would try a different parish priest and
talk to him about getting faith in God.

Regarding your status in life,
being single is not a bad thing. In fact, "fasting" from sex in this life and
sacrificing it to God will fill you with graces that most of us will never know.
That's why many people have suggested becoming a priest. I am a single man and
can assure you that it's okay. The only thing I would suggest is looking into
joining a seminary to truly find what God wants for you in this life. Ask your
local bishop or priest about attending a seminary. If you are truly dedicated to
knowing God and loving life, you will at least consider going to a
seminary.

I hope God heals your broken heart. Peace be with you.

Reply With Quote




#7
Old Yesterday, 5:35 pm

ServusHumilis's Avatar
New Member

Join Date: December 22, 2013
Posts: 574
Religion: Catholicus

Default Re: Considering leaving the faith and
returning to the synagogues to wait for someone else


Only thing I can suggest is to find yourself a
parish offering the Traditional Latin Mass. Once you do you'll have also found
yourself a community which I've found are quite unlike those at most Catholic
churches.


Last edited by ServusHumilis; Yesterday at 5:53 pm.

Reply With Quote




#8
Old Yesterday, 5:36 pm


Senior Member

Join Date: January 24, 2011
Posts: 8,983
Religion: Jewish

Default Re: Considering leaving the faith and
returning to the synagogues to wait for someone else


Quote:

Originally Posted by Jeremyah View Post
Another point was that in Judaism, I found
people ready and willing to be my mentors. Since becoming a Christian, I have
been left on my own. I am as alone now as I ever was as an atheist or as a
child. I've made acquaintances with the people that I attend church with but I'm
reluctant to call any of them friends.

No one calls when I miss church
to check up on me, no one is acting to be my spiritual adviser, counselor or
leader, the priest barely has any time for me.

I have been left to fly
sola. When I first converted, I would tell people that the difference between
Catholicism and protestantism was that Catholicism was about community and
loving each other as Christ loved us while protestantism, with all it's sola's,
was ultimately sola vita.

But I'm a Catholic and I live the Sola Vita now
as much as I ever did as a protestant. Why did I ever give up Judaism for
this?
You have obviously suffered a
great deal. Have you tried another parish? Maybe the apathy you have experienced
is peculiar to the members of the particular parish you belong to. Also, it
seems to me you do have a calling: that of evangelization. You might not be
aware of this, but Jews also believe that Christians are spreading the Word of
G-d and that this is all part of G-d's plan. Maybe you will get married
eventually or maybe not, but I think you should focus on your desire to spread
the Gospel. Finally, whether you decide to remain Catholic or go back to
Judaism, realize that neither choice is a good one if it is based mainly on what
the religion can do for you. Rather, it should be based on your commitment to
serve and love G-d and your fellow human beings in the best way you can.

Reply With Quote




#9
Old Yesterday, 5:37 pm

grasscutter's Avatar
Regular Member
Book Club
Member

Join Date: January 10, 2011
Posts: 2,816
Religion: Catholic

Default Re: Considering leaving the faith and
returning to the synagogues to wait for someone else


I guess you'll decide on a course of action that
you deem best for you.

One question though, which is more important to
you? Loving and obeying your Creator or having a wife? I pray that both happen
to you, of course but it may possibly not be so. Isn't your Creator ultimately
so much more important than a finite period of time on earth with a wife? A wife
who may die early of cancer, car accident, etc.

I truly understand your
loneliness and I think that it would be helpful to look in why you are having
difficulty attractive a prospective wife instead of insisting that parishioners
of a church should be taking this on as their personal
mission.

Parishioners have their own problems, too. Maybe you could reach
out and help others in your church. This would be very helpful to others and -
you never know - it might lead you to meet someone you would like to marry.

__________________
And they'll know we are
Christians by our love.

Reply With Quote




#10
Old Yesterday, 5:37 pm


Junior Member

Join Date: March 20, 2009
Posts: 242
Religion: Catholic

Default Re: Considering leaving the faith and
returning to the synagogues to wait for someone else


Can I offer you a few things I learned along the
way?

- The person God wants you to be with may not be ready yet, or He
still has some other plans for you before settling down. I didn't meet my wife
until I was almost 33. God had some things He needed me to learn before I would
be able to truly respect, appreciate, and be unselfish towards her. Had I met
her four years earlier, we very likely would have been ships passing in the
night. I didn't realize it then, but I do now.

- I suspect that the lack
of concern about your singleness is because Catholics have a place for single
people in the Church. St. Paul teaches that the single state allows one to focus
more fully on serving God. This is not necessarily as a
priest/nun/brother/sister. I know many very good men who are single, never
married, and very happy, whether they be 25 or 75.

- That being said,
please do not be offended that some people asked you to consider the priesthood.
Catholic families in general aren't nearly as encouraging of vocations as they
were several generations ago. Because not as many people are going into the
priesthood or religious life, some people want to do everything they can to
promote vocations. I would not be offended by the suggestion to explore a
vocation. In fact, depending on who is suggesting it, I would actually be
humbled that they thought highly enough of you, or see some very good qualities
in you, to make that recommendation. I know some people who I wouldn't recommend
for vocation discernment despite being single.

- Lastly, when I was
single, I did go through religious discernment. Obviously, I did not go to
seminary, but in the process I learned a great deal about both myself and the
Church. And, I feel the process helped teach some of the lessons I needed before
meeting my wife. One of those lessons is that things happen on God's schedule,
not ours. I needed to stop saying 'I want' and learn to ask 'what does God
want'.

I hope some of these will be helpful to you.

__________________
Eric B.
Husband & Father of Two
Knight of
Columbus Field Agent/PGK, Lector, Eucharistic Minister

Reply With Quote




#11
Old Yesterday, 5:38 pm


New Member

Join Date: November 28, 2012
Posts: 15
Religion: Roman Catholic

Default Re: Considering leaving the faith and
returning to the synagogues to wait for someone else


I'm very sorry to hear about your suffering. I'm
sure you've already heard this, but I would try a different parish priest and
talk to him about getting faith in God.

Regarding your status in life,
being single is not a bad thing. In fact, "fasting" from sex in this life and
sacrificing it to God will fill you with graces that most of us will never know.
That's why many people have suggested becoming a priest. I am a single man and
can assure you that it's okay. The only thing I would suggest is looking into
joining a seminary to truly find what God wants for you in this life. Ask your
local bishop or priest about attending a seminary. If you are truly dedicated to
knowing God and loving life, you will at least consider going to a
seminary.

I hope God heals your broken heart. Peace be with you.

Reply With Quote




#12
Old Yesterday, 5:39 pm


Senior Member

Join Date: May 19, 2004
Posts: 7,629
Religion: Catholic

Default Re: Considering leaving the faith and
returning to the synagogues to wait for someone else


It is hard for me to understand that you are not
helped in the Catholic Church.

Over the years, whenever I wanted to talk
something over with a priest they made time to do so.

There are holy
people and indifferent people in every religion. Because some Catholics are not
to your liking doesn't eclipse the truth of the Church.

Reply With Quote




#13
Old Yesterday, 5:47 pm


Regular Member

Join Date: August 2, 2013
Posts: 707
Religion: Catholic

Default Re: Considering leaving the faith and
returning to the synagogues to wait for someone else


From your post you have expressed the need to
marry and are looking for religious community support to this aim.
Firstly I
can understand the loneliness that calls for a wife. Every man feels it as part
of his wholesome nature should.
However to mix this very natural desire with
some emotionally based window shopping for the religion which comes up with the
Christmas present is logically unsound and somewhat childish.
It is not any
religion's role to fulfill your desires here and now. However it is your role to
continually ask your God for His assistance in finding you a good spouse. You
seem to forget that the girl's free will will have a major impact on your quest.
Therefore you must do the hard work of good presentation and the correct manner
of searching for a good woman. Your mental affliction will not help.
Get real
and realise that religion is about God and His relationship with you. Putting
forward your allegiance to a God that fills up the present bag is not the way to
find the truth.
Don't get me wrong, I can understand your pain, but you have
to be the master of your own destiny in finding the strengths within yourself
that will attract a good woman, not flailing around blaming every God you find
who doesn't immediately come to your party.

Reply With Quote




#14
Old Yesterday, 5:54 pm


New Member

Join Date: February 20, 2014
Posts: 327
Religion: Catholic

Default Re: Considering leaving the faith and
returning to the synagogues to wait for someone else


Quote:

Originally Posted by DJgang View Post
I'm really not sure how to address this whole
issue. I find it overwhelming and wonder if you aren't co dependent on people in
general. All your actions have been reactions to what other people do "for
you".
See? That's exactly what I'm talking
about. I just don't matter to you at all. So long as I'm working to serve you
and the cause, every thing is just fine but as soon as I have any needs,
suddenly, all that goes out the window and I'm just being selfish. I'm here to
meet everyone else's needs but no one is here to meet mine.

NO! I matter
too. I'm a person, just as much as anyone else, and it's time you people got
used to it.

Reply With Quote



#15
Old Yesterday, 5:59 pm


New Member

Join Date: February 20, 2014
Posts: 327
Religion: Catholic

Default Re: Considering leaving the faith and
returning to the synagogues to wait for someone else


Quote:

Originally Posted by SybilMolly View Post
It sort of sounds like you give up on your
beliefs when they don't seem to work out for you
especially.
So long as it works out for
everyone else, to hell with me, right?


Quote:
What exactly should Catholics be helping you with in regards to a
wife?
1) Every Catholic should be praying night
and day for God to get me and every other single married.

2) Every parish
should have the following:
a) A team that work with singles to prepare them
for marriage in whatever way they need to be prepared.
c) Some kind of
singles' ministry
b) A team of people to act as matchmakers