Wednesday, November 13, 2013

catholic answers forum --Where does it say that the Holy Spirit can infallibly guide the believers on an individual basis? 1working4christ2

Thread Tools Search Thread Display
  #1  
Old Yesterday, 2:20 pm
PJM PJM is offline
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: August 31, 2008
Posts: 9,406
Religion: Informed, practicing RomanCatholic
Default second question for our non-catholic brethern

It seems clear that
[1] God did start a New religion [set of faith beliefs]

[2} did found a new church [structure and organization]

Mt. 10:1-8
Mt. 16:18-19
John 17:14-20
Mk. 16: 14-15
Mt. 28:16-20 are evidence of this.

SO DEAR FRIENDS MY QUESTION IS:

Did Christ give to the Apostles the Power and Authority to

[1] Teach this new faith FULLY and CORRECTLY?

[2] Give [transfer] the necesary Powers and Authority to them?

God Bless you!
Patrick
__________________
PJM


http://working4christ2.wordpress.com

Can we partake of God's GLORY and NOT partake of His PASSION? NO!


A.B. Fulton Sheen: "The truth is the truth even if nobody believes it, and a lie is still a lie, even if everybody believes it."
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old Yesterday, 2:23 pm
Junior Member
 
Join Date: February 16, 2012
Posts: 170
Religion: Christian
Default Re: second question for our non-catholic brethern

1. Yes.

2. To who?
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old Yesterday, 2:26 pm
SteveVH's Avatar
Senior Member
 
Join Date: March 18, 2009
Posts: 6,110
Religion: Catholic
Default Re: second question for our non-catholic brethern

Quote:
Originally Posted by Traverse View Post

2. To who?
To the bishops who they ordained by the laying on of hands.
__________________
"Let the time come when those who should oblige the servant of God, do the contrary to him, and what degree of patience and humility he has then, that is the degree he has and no more." - St. Francis of Assisi
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old Yesterday, 3:49 pm
Trial Membership
 
Join Date: November 11, 2013
Posts: 36
Religion: Christian, Protestant
Default Re: second question for our non-catholic brethern

Quote:
Originally Posted by PJM View Post
It seems clear that
[1] God did start a New religion [set of faith beliefs]
Protestants are fond of saying that He did away with religion and established relationship, but that depends on how each party defines "religion." lol

Quote:
[2} did found a new church [structure and organization]

Mt. 10:1-8
Mt. 16:18-19
John 17:14-20
Mk. 16: 14-15
Mt. 28:16-20 are evidence of this.
The ekklesia does have organization as long as it is recognized that the ekklesia, or church, are the out-called ones themselves.

Quote:
SO DEAR FRIENDS MY QUESTION IS:

Did Christ give to the Apostles the Power and Authority to

[1] Teach this new faith FULLY and CORRECTLY?

[2] Give [transfer] the necesary Powers and Authority to them?

God Bless you!
Patrick
I don't believe so, not in the way I'm assuming you mean. For example, one scriptural teaching was that there is no Jew nor Gentile delineation in Christ. So, when Peter was called out by Paul for wrong action in regards to separating from Gentile believers when eating, it shows that the Apostles could err.

The Holy Spirit is the one that is promised to lead and guide infallibly. So, I say from my perspective it is the Holy Spirit that is both necessary and sufficient to lead and guide believers into all Truth, and I believe from scripture that that can apply to all believers regardless of their title or position in the organizational structure of the church.
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old Yesterday, 4:01 pm
PJM PJM is offline
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: August 31, 2008
Posts: 9,406
Religion: Informed, practicing RomanCatholic
Default Re: second question for our non-catholic brethern

Quote:
=Traverse;11394392]1. Yes.

2. To who?
"THEM" = th Apostles and the Leaders of today's Catholic church. Evident and specified in the passges I referenced.

God Bless you,
Patrick
__________________
PJM


http://working4christ2.wordpress.com

Can we partake of God's GLORY and NOT partake of His PASSION? NO!


A.B. Fulton Sheen: "The truth is the truth even if nobody believes it, and a lie is still a lie, even if everybody believes it."
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old Yesterday, 4:03 pm
PJM PJM is offline
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: August 31, 2008
Posts: 9,406
Religion: Informed, practicing RomanCatholic
Default Re: second question for our non-catholic brethern

Quote:
=Kliska;11394818]Protestants are fond of saying that He did away with religion and established relationship, but that depends on how each party defines "religion." lol



The ekklesia does have organization as long as it is recognized that the ekklesia, or church, are the out-called ones themselves.



I don't believe so, not in the way I'm assuming you mean. For example, one scriptural teaching was that there is no Jew nor Gentile delineation in Christ. So, when Peter was called out by Paul for wrong action in regards to separating from Gentile believers when eating, it shows that the Apostles could err.

The Holy Spirit is the one that is promised to lead and guide infallibly. So, I say from my perspective it is the Holy Spirit that is both necessary and sufficient to lead and guide believers into all Truth, and I believe from scripture that that can apply to all believers regardless of their title or position in the organizational structure of the church.
The Pope and Magisterium can error in matters of "church practice" BUT NOT; NEVER-EVER in All matters of Faith belief and Morals. This is the teaching of the CC.
__________________
PJM


http://working4christ2.wordpress.com

Can we partake of God's GLORY and NOT partake of His PASSION? NO!


A.B. Fulton Sheen: "The truth is the truth even if nobody believes it, and a lie is still a lie, even if everybody believes it."
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old Yesterday, 4:33 pm
Trial Membership
 
Join Date: November 11, 2013
Posts: 36
Religion: Christian, Protestant
Default Re: second question for our non-catholic brethern

Quote:
Originally Posted by PJM View Post
The Pope and Magisterium can error in matters of "church practice" BUT NOT; NEVER-EVER in All matters of Faith belief and Morals. This is the teaching of the CC.
Right, I do understand that is the RC position, but we protestants tend not to believe that is true, or else most of us wouldn't be protestants. lol Our position is that believers, including the pope and those comprising the magisterium, can err both in their teaching by action and teaching by word.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old Yesterday, 6:45 pm
Regular Member
 
Join Date: April 30, 2013
Posts: 567
Religion: Catholic
Default Re: second question for our non-catholic brethern

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kliska View Post
Right, I do understand that is the RC position, but we protestants tend not to believe that is true, or else most of us wouldn't be protestants. lol Our position is that believers, including the pope and those comprising the magisterium, can err both in their teaching by action and teaching by word.
" .... And I say to thee: that thou art Peter, and upon this rock I shall build MY CHURCH; and the gates of Hell shall not prevail against it." - Matthew 16:18

So is it that you have a beef against Matthew, the NT, the veracity of Jesus' words, or what?

If Jesus just meant that His Church would only reside in Simon Peter until his death, without some sort of logical Apostolic Succession, then His Church would be doomed to a short life or a descent into chaos and schism. Do you think the latter is what Jesus had in mind?
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old Yesterday, 6:51 pm
Trial Membership
 
Join Date: November 11, 2013
Posts: 36
Religion: Christian, Protestant
Default Re: second question for our non-catholic brethern

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mount Carmel View Post
" .... And I say to thee: that thou art Peter, and upon this rock I shall build MY CHURCH; and the gates of Hell shall not prevail against it." - Matthew 16:18

So is it that you have a beef against Matthew, the NT, the veracity of Jesus' words, or what?

If Jesus just meant that His Church would only reside in Simon Peter until his death, without some sort of logical Apostolic Succession, then His Church would be doomed to a short life or a descent into chaos and schism. Do you think the latter is what Jesus had in mind?
Again, I won't be arguing the point, just clarifying. The book of Matthew is inspired scripture and is not wrong, and Jesus, God the Son, is perfect and does not err, it is neither scripture nor Christ that I disagree with, rather the interpretation and application of the verse(s).
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old Yesterday, 7:01 pm
Regular Member
 
Join Date: April 30, 2013
Posts: 567
Religion: Catholic
Default Re: second question for our non-catholic brethern

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kliska View Post
Again, I won't be arguing the point, just clarifying. The book of Matthew is inspired scripture and is not wrong, and Jesus, God the Son, is perfect and does not err, it is neither scripture nor Christ that I disagree with, rather the interpretation and application of the verse(s).
Then would you do us the favour of pointing out just what 'your' interpretation is, and how 'you' arrived at it? It seems to me that the Roman Catholic church takes it literally AND logically - are 'we' missing something?
Reply With Quote
  #11  
Old Yesterday, 7:25 pm
Trial Membership
 
Join Date: November 11, 2013
Posts: 36
Religion: Christian, Protestant
Default Re: second question for our non-catholic brethern

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mount Carmel View Post
Then would you do us the favour of pointing out just what 'your' interpretation is, and how 'you' arrived at it? It seems to me that the Roman Catholic church takes it literally AND logically - are 'we' missing something?
That, to my understanding, would be akin to proselytizing, and would lead to a long back-and-forth over interpretation. I'm not here to do that. But I can tell you that the way many Protestants, including me, understand scriptural teaching is that the Holy Spirit brings understanding and guidance to believers. So, the "how" is through studying scripture, including the Greek, with guidance from the Spirit and prayerful consideration. I take it literally and logically as well. Do a quick search on any search engine for Protestant interpretations of that verse, and you'll find them.

Also, I hope I'm wrong, but it seems your tone may be a bit hostile, of course the typed word is tricky that way, I hope I haven't offended.
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old Yesterday, 8:16 pm
Junior Member
 
Join Date: June 17, 2013
Posts: 995
Religion: Baha'i
Default Re: second question for our non-catholic brethern

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kliska View Post
The Holy Spirit is the one that is promised to lead and guide infallibly. So, I say from my perspective it is the Holy Spirit that is both necessary and sufficient to lead and guide believers into all Truth, and I believe from scripture that that can apply to all believers regardless of their title or position in the organizational structure of the church.
Hi Kliska, what Scripture passage(s) are you referring to here?
Where does it say that the Holy Spirit can infallibly guide the believers on an individual basis?
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old Yesterday, 9:14 pm
Regular Member
 
Join Date: April 30, 2013
Posts: 567
Religion: Catholic
Default Re: second question for our non-catholic brethern

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kliska View Post
That, to my understanding, would be akin to proselytizing, and would lead to a long back-and-forth over interpretation. I'm not here to do that. But I can tell you that the way many Protestants, including me, understand scriptural teaching is that the Holy Spirit brings understanding and guidance to believers. So, the "how" is through studying scripture, including the Greek, with guidance from the Spirit and prayerful consideration. I take it literally and logically as well. Do a quick search on any search engine for Protestant interpretations of that verse, and you'll find them.

Also, I hope I'm wrong, but it seems your tone may be a bit hostile, of course the typed word is tricky that way, I hope I haven't offended.
Not so, just questioning - curious.

The problem as I perceive it is that if the Holy Spirit only directs us on an individual basis, there then appears to be rich hunting grounds for 'Old Nick' to operate and sow his own 'brands of interpretation(s)' and personal feelings that we are being correctly and more infallibly 'discerning'. Satan must love the 'individual' approach to spiritual matters, divide is often at the core of his approach - 'divide and conquer'. Jesus expressed the oneness and unity of His Church when appointing Simon Peter as His 'stand in'; that there was/is but one Church, not many individual/personal Churches.

The Church that Jesus instituted when installing Simon Peter as its head should always be our signal reference point, IMHO.
Reply With Quote
  #14  
Old Yesterday, 9:20 pm
New Member
 
Join Date: January 12, 2013
Posts: 74
Religion: Protestant
Default Re: second question for our non-catholic brethern

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mount Carmel View Post
" .... And I say to thee: that thou art Peter, and upon this rock I shall build MY CHURCH; and the gates of Hell shall not prevail against it." - Matthew 16:18

So is it that you have a beef against Matthew, the NT, the veracity of Jesus' words, or what?

If Jesus just meant that His Church would only reside in Simon Peter until his death, without some sort of logical Apostolic Succession, then His Church would be doomed to a short life or a descent into chaos and schism. Do you think the latter is what Jesus had in mind?
You have omitted the first part of the passage. And Jesus said "who do you say that I am?'; Peter responds "You are the Christ the Son of the living God". This is the Rock that Christ built the Church on. Faith in Jesus Christ not upon Peter. That is the way Protestants understand it.
Reply With Quote
  #15  
Old Today, 2:54 am
Junior Member
 
Join Date: February 13, 2006
Posts: 183
Default Re: second question for our non-catholic brethern

Quote:
Originally Posted by PJM View Post
It seems clear that
[1] God did start a New religion [set of faith beliefs]

[2} did found a new church [structure and organization]

Mt. 10:1-8
Mt. 16:18-19
John 17:14-20
Mk. 16: 14-15
Mt. 28:16-20 are evidence of this.

SO DEAR FRIENDS MY QUESTION IS:

Did Christ give to the Apostles the Power and Authority to

[1] Teach this new faith FULLY and CORRECTLY?

[2] Give [transfer] the necesary Powers and Authority to them?

God Bless you!
Patrick
I think your question is answered by a quote from Jesus:

Quote:
Verily, verily, I say unto you, The servant is not greater than his lord; neither he that is sent greater than he that sent him. - John 13:16
So what do we conclude from this? Jesus himself taught this new faith fully and correctly.

No disciple of Jesus can ever exceed Him in understanding and Truth. However, it is completely possible (and unarguably true) that a disciple of Jesus can be less than Jesus in their ability to understand and teach this new religion. To argue otherwise would be to say that the Apostles were equal to Jesus, which is clearly false.

Thus, from the very first step, from Jesus to the Apostles, we have a downgrade in the fullness and truth of the teachings of this new religion, because after Jesus left, it was being taught by those who had an understanding that was less than that of their Lord.

Furthermore, any disciple of the Apostles can at best be equal to the Apostle who taught him, and is most likely going to be less than the Apostle. This is also virtually a given, since we do not typically put the teachings of the disciples of the Apostles on the same tier as the teachings of the Apostles themselves.

Continuing down the chain, any disciple of a disciple of an Apostle can only be less than or equal to the disciple of the Apostle who taught him. Continue like this for 2,000 years.

So it seems to me that the answer to both of your questions is "No."
Reply With Quote

No comments:

Post a Comment